Journal Entry
Stochastic Global Awareness
November 30th 2007 at 2:20 pm
I just love this phrase “Stochastic Global Awareness” that Chad Orzel used to refer to the odd way he finds news via various back channel personal and random blogs.
I don’t follow a lot of mainstream news sources any more, because they mostly just piss me off, so I end up getting most of my news from an assortment of blogs and LiveJournals and other web sites, which means that I have a weirdly spotty understanding of what’s going on in the world.
I’m interested in this because after reading a book about media matters I cut news watching out my life. I think it was the book ‘Fear.’
Here’s the thing. There is no concerted Media conspiracy other than our own participatory inclination to pay more attention to shocking or bad news than good. Since newsrooms became money-making and advertising-focused (if you’re my age, go see a movie call NETWORK as a starter) it’s easier to serve up bloody headlines, and a healthy platter of fear. Because it gets you more viewers and more attention. Ditto controversy.
Case in point, having done professional blogging and consulting, I’ll say that I can easily predict affects headlines and initial first sentence controversy or fear headlines will incite feedback and eyeballs. If I want ad money, or attention, it’s hard not to, just by the dint of how your readership responds, to give in.
Therefore, headline or standard news sources are actually damaging, I believe, to any healthy attempt to actually understand what is going on the world.
Anecdote: when I was fifteen I visited an elderly in-law who’d been living in her house for a decade or so with home health care. At some point I realized that if I walked into a room with her alone, she’d scurry away, wide eyed with what looked like fear. My stepdad explained that after 10 years of watching TV and being out of contact with the general population, she believed that teenagers were *all* thieves, murderers and rapists. It’s all she ever saw on TV news. The world had gone downhill for her. Outside it was some Mad Max-like world.
A second anecdote: when Hurricane Marilyn hit St. Thomas the local Woolworth’s collapsed, the building all but falling apart. While most of the rest of the island, damaged and windswept, crawled out from underneath the rubble, a number of people looted Woolworths.
If you were watching news networks, it looked like the 100,000 people of St. Thomas had descended into lawlessness and the whole island was looting and going nuts while people were being medi-vaced out.
Although Chad wonders if he shouldn’t get more active about news viewing, I wonder if a filtered and localized stochastic awareness of news by chance and general diffusion isn’t a more efficient distributive mechanism than any news.
Although I do watch the Daily Show with Jon Stewart, I’ve managed to cut all news shows out of my life. If I hear about an intriguing story I tend to google around for primary or local sources (ie: I read soldier blogs and Iraqi local blogs for news about the war, not newspapers) if I want a source.
As a result, unlike most of the people around me, I’m not convinced we live in the end times. I’m impressed with all the people running around just being human in all the various locales and on all sides of the various issues.
Filed in Journal. You can subscribe to the RSS feed for this entry to keep track of comments. You can also use this URL to trackback.
5 Responses so far
Leave a comment
Your host:
Tobias is a Caribbean-born SF/F novelist who lives in Ohio.
Get in touch:
tobias@tobiasbuckell.com
AIM: tobiasbuckell
Latest Comments
Stephen on Latest IGMS book review column up (2)
Kerry on Sly Mongoose review copies (hello reviewers) (3)
Tobias Buckell on Shaun Duke review of Ragamuffin (4)
Joey on My freelanceiversary gift to myself: Scotch (14)
James on A pamphlet on writing? (7)
Stephen Granade on Two freaking years, man, two years (my two year freelanceiversary) (13)
Mark Terry on New Space Opera authors (6)
Two freaking years, man, two years (my two year freelanceiversary) at Tobias Buckell Online on Making A Jump (13)
Twitter blog:
-@sarahgilbert for an external hardrive consider: http://tinyurl.com/6ft8ht, water/fire proof hdd 8 hrs ago
-@pablod that would be awesome, thank you so much! Hey, is there anywhere I can find the JPG of Ragamuffin with the nebula sticker? 9 hrs ago
-@pablod that's an awesome print! 10 hrs ago
...More updates...
Video Posts:
Buckellcast #7
I interview Fantasy novelist Joshua Palmatier
Buckellcast #6
Presentation on creating a writing career to the Alpha workshop. Pt. 1 and Pt 2
Buckellcast #5
An interview with Cult Pop's Jim Hall about my new novel Ragamuffin.
Buckellcast #4
In this episode I unpack my new Mac Pro and show off my office. I also talk about how I plot novels and what I love and hate about being a writer.
Top Commenters
Rachel (1)
Mark Terry (1)
Steve Buchheit (1)
Wyman Cooke (1)
Currently Reading & Enjoying:
Most Commented
Diversity in science fiction markets (82)
What does it mean to be this Caribbean writer? (74)
Science Fiction anti-Christian? (61)
How Much Does a Science Fiction or Fantasy Writer Make? (54)
The Brini Maxwell Show (52)
I just sold 3 books! (50)
Transracial writing redux (47)
Survey: How many novels did you write before selling your first? (44)
Locus Bestseller (39)
Harriet Klausner redux... redux? (34)















1. Rachel on Nov 30th, 2007 at 3:12 pm
Me, I get 90% of my news from The WEEK: a non-partisan round-up of the past week’s stories and what everyone is saying about them.
And, if you’re looking for positive news, including what individuals and other entities are doing to try to make the world a better place, I highly recommend Ode magazine, which bills itself as being aimed at “intelligent optimists.”
2. Mark Terry on Nov 30th, 2007 at 4:33 pm
I get news from all over the place, like MSN.com, Time.com, Time Magazine, USA Today and various blogs, etc. (And, oh yeah, the voices in my head, telling me…)
Anyway, as a journalist, it’s always useful for me to remember the famed credo IF IT BLEEDS, IT LEADS as a way for me to interpret how news comes to me.
I will say, however, that the local news has gotten worse and worse, and I think, since the one I occasionally watch is an ABC affiliate, that they’ve got a lot of gall acting as if I’m really all that f-ing interested in who got booted off DANCING WITH THE STARS the night before as part of their 18 minutes (12 minutes of advertisements out of 30 minutes) of “news.”
3. Steve Buchheit on Nov 30th, 2007 at 9:09 pm
The last time I watched local news (except for emergencies right near me, like a train derailment this summer or for weather) they had stories from California, NYC, Europe and Asia. Not very local, so I switched to venues that actually provide in-depth reporting sans political rhetoric (one of the reasons I stopped reading many mil blogs, too political).
4. Wyman Cooke on Dec 3rd, 2007 at 12:01 am
My news sources are eclectic. I read Drudge and the New York Times website. The Huffington Post occasionally. I watch network news though not as regularly as I used to. I don’t have cable or dish. I miss the old network news, before the accountants got a hold of it. Back in the late 80’s each network had multiple crews covering the Chinese student protests and the collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe. Nowadays it needs a war just about to get coverage.
5. Tobias Buckell on Dec 3rd, 2007 at 5:13 pm
These are all some great suggestions. Thanks Rachel. I don’t read NYT or Huffington, but I do hit Drudge on occasion.
>Anyway, as a journalist, it’s always useful for me to remember the famed credo IF IT BLEEDS, IT LEADS as a way for me to interpret how news comes to me.
Seriously, yeah!