Journal Entry

John Scalzi’s very Merry Christmas gift

Scalzi gets a whole page in the NY Times Book Review section. Awesome!

Here are John Scalzi’s comments on the neat event.

Of course I thought the summary was a bit bullshit:

And if he uses that work to articulate a firm position on the political issues that will inevitably define his historical moment, take a stance that considerate readers might potentially disagree with, and even risk the possibility that a half-century later, some petulant, know-nothing critic will dismiss his ideas as dangerous and obsolete, then Scalzi truly will have earned his place alongside Heinlein in the canon of military science fiction — and not a moment too soon.

10316763Itzkoff fundamentally seems to believe that unless you’re a polemicist you’re not a Great Writer ™. Ewww. I hate that. And he completely undercuts the praise he just made of Scalzi’s work by basically challenging Scalzi in his next book to denounce or affirm the fascism Itzkoff believes he sees in Starship Troopers, or else he won’t consider it a great work, which is a cheap and manipulative way of ending the column.

Still, yay Scalzi!

Filed under the topic On Writing on December 23rd 2006 at 3:19 pm. You can subscribe to the RSS feed for this entry to keep track of comments. You can also use to trackback.

Your host:

Tobias is a Caribbean-born SF/F novelist who lives in Ohio.

Contact me:

tobias@tobiasbuckell.com
AIM: tobiasbuckell


Latest Comments

Matt Ruff on Underwater Skyscrapers (2)
Stephen Watkins on China ups the ante on rail (8)
Steve Buchheit on Colonialism 2.0? (3)
Sophy ZS Adani on SF Hall of Fame inductees (2)
Tobias Buckell on Friday’s latest chapter of It’s All Just A Draft: On Rejection (5)

Popular this month

In the ER
Repeat
Why my books are no longer for sale via Amazon
Introducing...
That (not so much) crumbling core of Western Europe's military might


Twitter feed


Hmmm, http://rudder.com/ looks like it does a lot of stuff I did in http://bit.ly/df5E6Z but more automated. Nifty. 47 mins ago

Ya'll have about 1/2 hour to hit me with more questions before I go silent ;-) 3 hrs ago

Okay twitter, it's Friday. Ask me a question, let's rap. 4 hrs ago

The outline is still ok. I'll keep the spam killerz story on the backburner as a side project 4 when I'm done with the 2 primary projects. 4 hrs ago

After 1000 + bouncebacks in my inbox today due to some spammer using my email address as the 'reply to' address, I'd like vengeance 4 hrs ago

More updates...


Currently Reading & Enjoying:



Booklife: Strategies and Survival Tips for the 21st Century Writer


Free Fiction

Novels

Read the first 1/3 free of:
-Crystal Rain: First 1/3 [RTF]
-Ragamuffin-First 1/3 [RTF]
-Sly Mongoose-First 1/3 [RTF]

Short Stories

Toy Planes
The Fish Merchant [pdf]
Her
The Shackles of Freedom (with Mike Resnick)
Necahual
Four Eyes
Aerophilia
Shoah Sry (with Ilsa J. Bick [pdf]

Audio

Smooth Talking
Her
A Green Thumb
Waiting For The Zephyr